Madeline, I had to do that too, and I felt the same about AOL, but I migrated it there, because I can always still change my mind. it was two clicks, and worked fine, I still see my email history, but I don't know if I still will once my verizon shuts down. I told my IT dept they'll have to be more lenient about AOL addresses, because it's not only old farts using it now.
As an aside, I almost dropped my fiance early on in the relationship when he said he had an AOL account.