I went through this proposal from AR and thin the biggest open issues are:
a. Website upkeep is extra
b. Socialcast upkeep may not be included - their proposal may require us moving to their preferred solution
c. Events like MOTM are not included
Some of the other areas - such as overseeing meetings and providing direction to the group will only be of as much value as we make use of. If we have a strong committee in that area then I suspect they will be of value. However, AR is most certainly not going to engage in debate or spend lengthy periods of contemplation regarding different directions the group may or may not contemplate taking.
Ultimately I think an alternative to a $4,000/mo AR type contract could be someone doing the bookkeeping for $1,000/mo and some up and running consulting (possibly from someone like Joanne Benzer though I haven't spoken with her) for perhaps $5,000 to $10,000.
However, if the group is actively contemplating expanding and going to publishers like Acumatica and Sage and working closer with them throughout the year (meetings, events, etc) and those publishers are willing to spend bigger money then something such as AR may be a worthwhile investment.
This question of expansion vs stay-as-is is really a board level question since if you ask our core of members most of them will vote to solve error 47's faster rather than be forward thinking. It's up to the board to make more difficult strategic decisions.
The long and short of this, my gut says our membership still thinks of themselves as ""Sageresellers"" and might be content to ride this train until it derails. When I'm at MOTM and hear member comments like ""I'm ok with adding Acumatica but it just has to be existing 90 Minds - no pure Acumatica VARS"" , I don't think that's realistic (or very smart) and I don't think a shortsighted group like that probably requires as much oversight as AR has proposed.
My TL;DR:
If the vision for 90 Minds is going to remain a comfortable sageresellers type group, consider more of an outsourced admin assistance/bookkeeper.
If the vision for 90 Minds is going to be that we actively diversify, open sections for products which our members are diversifying toward (ie Acumatica) which would include admitting Acumuatica only partners (to areas that they would NOT be interacting with Sage info) which would include actively engaging (for a fee paid by publishers) as advocates for our members, which would include actively expanding some of our reach and keeping a strong web presence. Then an AR type managed service makes sense.
We need to set the vision for 90 Minds (maybe even a name change to toss the perception that 90 relates to MAS90) and then select the appropriate structural support.
I have already relayed that I am not able to remain as President due to the time commitments of the group interfering with my business. So it seems to make the most sense as our next step to decide upon who the go forward team (Board) may be and then have that decision about strategic direction for the group.
I think we should look to schedule a call so that we can all discuss this next Thursday March 3, 2016 at 1pm ET.
Does that work for everyone?