I thought the license might be the case, but I have a Connector license. So, I tried it on my laptop that only has Sage 2017 and 2018 on it, no earlier versions, and the consolidation works. The only consolidation option is the menu item labeled ""Consolidation Report Designer"". On my desktop computer, I have versions of Sage going back to 2015 and on my 2017 version, I don't have the menu item above, instead I have ""Report Designer Add-In Consolidation"". It must be something on my desktop PC. I wonder if I should reinstall the Add-In from years ago.